top of page
  • Writer's pictureFine Finish Builders

Fiberglass vs. Concrete vs. Vinyl Pools: Which is Best for You?

Updated: Sep 25, 2023

When it comes to inground pools, homeowners have several options: fiberglass vs. concrete vs. vinyl pools. But which is the best choice for your backyard oasis? Let's break down the debate, covering cost, durability, and maintenance.

Fiberglass vs. Concrete Pools

  • Cost: A frequent question on many homeowners' minds is, "are fiberglass pools cheaper than concrete?" In terms of initial installation, fiberglass pools often come with a more moderate price tag compared to their concrete counterparts. However, when considering long-term maintenance, some argue that the cost of concrete pool vs. fiberglass evens out.

  • Durability: Concrete pools offer the advantage of being customizable in shape and size. They're sturdy but require regular maintenance to prevent cracks or surface roughness. Fiberglass pools, on the other hand, are smooth, resistant to algae buildup, and can withstand shifts in the ground.

  • Appearance and Feel: Some people find the fiberglass pool liner offers a pleasant smoothness compared to the textured surface of concrete. Additionally, do fiberglass pools have liners? No, they don’t. Their smooth surface is inherent to the material.

Fiberglass vs. Vinyl Pools

  • Cost: When comparing the fiberglass vs. vinyl pool cost, vinyl liner pools typically emerge as the budget-friendly option. However, vinyl liners require replacement every 5-9 years, impacting long-term costs.

  • Durability: Vinyl pool versus fiberglass is an interesting comparison. Vinyl pools can be susceptible to punctures or tears, whereas fiberglass is more rigid and durable.

  • Appearance: Some homeowners prefer the aesthetic of a vinyl liner pool cost vs. fiberglass, given the variety of liner patterns available. However, a significant point to note is that fiberglass pools don’t have the liner replacement concerns of vinyl.

Concrete vs. Vinyl Pools

Do concrete pools have liners? Generally, no. They are constructed using gunite or shotcrete and are finished with plaster or other materials.

Vinyl liner pools, conversely, are built over a framework in the ground and necessitate a liner. An inground pool without a liner typically means it’s a concrete or fiberglass pool.

The Verdict

  • Pros and Cons: Fiberglass vs. Concrete vs. Vinyl Pools pros and cons are diverse. While fiberglass offers ease of installation and smoothness, concrete provides customization. Vinyl pools are initially more affordable but come with liner replacement costs.

  • Overall Value: Is fiberglass pool better than concrete or vinyl? It depends on your needs. For a balance of durability and maintenance, many homeowners lean towards fiberglass.

  • Final Thoughts: Whether you're considering a radiant pool vs. fiberglass, fiberglass vs. cement pools, or any other combination, it’s essential to evaluate your budget, maintenance preferences, and desired aesthetics. After all, your pool should be a reflection of your personal oasis.

Remember, every pool type has its own set of advantages. Whichever you choose, summer days by the pool are sure to be enjoyable.

13 views0 comments


bottom of page